Neville describes returning to a cataleptic body from other worlds

Neville says he has many times been shut out of his body in other worlds and returned to find the body he had left on a bed, chair or couch cataleptic and unmovable for twenty or twenty-five seconds.
Date (happened)
15 January 1968
unresolved
  1. 15 January 1968 stated · preferred
    Source Live the Answer Now ¶31L1.6 full-passage adjudication against the source lecture preferred delivery.
    Said as
    counted from Live the Answer Now ¶31
    Reasoning Specific document header/delivery and explicit relative timing outweigh the competing coarse title-date inference.
  2. before 10 November 1958 stated · doubtful
    Source Live the Answer Now ¶31"many times", told in Live the Answer Now (nid 1051)
    Reasoning || v1.1/l7/passage-inherit: lowered `certain` -> `doubtful`. This date was inherited from lecture node 1051, whose own 1958-11-10 delivery claim has been refuted, and no other node in the corpus holds that date live — so the only witness for this date is one the corpus has disproved. Lowered, never refuted (#2461 §1 rule (b)): what collapsed is the evidence for WHEN, not the event. This row was reached through a PASSAGE source, which every earlier rule-(b) pass was structurally blind to.
  3. before 15 January 1968 bound
    Source Live the Answer Now ¶31'I have been shut out, oh, many times' before the Live the Answer Now telling
    Reasoning Passage 528820 describes repeated completed experiences ('I have been shut out, oh, many times') by the time Neville tells them. Lecture 1051's 1968-01-15 delivery is independently corroborated by its head dateline and surviving catalogue claim, while 1958-11-10 is refuted. The evidence therefore supports a certain upper bound before the telling day, not an exact occurrence on that day.
Persons
Neville Goddard
Told / reported
  1. 15 January 1968 conclusion
    Why dc1-agreement-20261004, pm-actor-551 (PM 8702)
    Reasoning 1 claim, no conflict: 1968-01-15 (node:1051).
  2. 15 January 1968 stated
    Source Live the Answer NowLive the Answer Now (nid 1051), telling 1051-4, told 1968-01-15
Sources

Source

  • Live the Answer Now ¶31 (I have been shut out, oh, many times, and returned to this body that is cataleptic. I’ve been so completely shutout in these worlds that this which I left on a bed or on a chair or on a couch is cataleptic when I return.)
1 tellings, oldest first. A date in brackets shows how it is known; "circa", "after" and "possible" dates are rough.
Date Lecture or book Telling Passage
1968-01-15 [exact/certain/final] Live the Answer Now May I tell you, it’s the most interesting experience…don’t get panicky…you’ll come back. I have been shut out, oh, many times, and returned to this body that is cataleptic. I’ve been so completely shut out in these worlds that this which I left on a bed or on a chair or on a couch is cataleptic when I return. Can’t move it for a while, maybe twenty, twenty-five seconds, and then suddenly I can animate it again. If I didn’t get back, they’d cut it up to see why I died, and they’ll come to some conclusion. But if they were honest with themselves, they’ll see no physical reason, I just didn’t… 528820