A friend reminded Neville that the two of them had visited Dr. Kimberly four weeks before he died, that Neville talked with him for about an hour, and that Kimberly afterwards said Neville knows from experience while he himself knows only from what Neville said — the friend then asking how he could know before dying.
Date (happened)
four weeks before Dr. Kimberly died
unresolved
four weeks before Dr. Kimberly died
relative · probable
before 1967
bound · possible
Reasoning
Qualifying passage ids [536721] belong to telling lecture nids [1311]. Each listed lecture contributes the selected safe envelope year 1967 (MAX of its non-refuted delivery years); 1967 is the MIN across telling lectures.
before 27 November 1967
bound
Why
Tightens the phase4 L6a envelope from before 1967 to before 1967-11-27.
Reasoning
L6a envelope tightened to the telling day of nid 1311 (certain delivery 1967-11-27); same premise, finer precision. The phase4 L6a bound on this event is `before 1967`, an envelope over delivery YEARS computed without reading text. Its premise is that the fact is true by the time it is told; on that same premise the DAY of the telling is a strictly better upper bound. Nothing is re-decided — the bound is stated to the precision the evidence always supported. The delivery claim for 1967-11-27 on nid 1311 is held at `certain` by the corpus, which is what carries this claim. #2274; the L6a row stands beside this one.
Sources
Source
- Sent to Disturb With Truth ¶5 (As my friend said to me, “Neville, you know four weeks before Dr. Kimberly died you and I visited him. He said to me afterwards—you talked to him for about an hour—‘Neville knows. I do not know, not from experience; I know only from what he said.’ Now, h…)