Neville reflects on defending his earthly parents

Explaining why Catholics defend the Pope, he speaks of his own earthly parents: he would justify any mistake of his father and would not stand for anyone criticising his mother, who died in 1941.
Date (happened)
1941
unresolved
  1. 1941 stated · preferred
    Source Spiritual States ¶69"she’s been gone since 1941", told in Spiritual States (nid 1770)
  2. 1941 stated · refuted
    Source Spiritual States ¶69passage 543859, 'she's been gone since 1941'
    Why Append-only refutation; no replacement calendar date is stated.
    Reasoning The quoted year belongs to the mother's death, a background fact. The event record concerns Neville's attitude of defending his parents, which the passage presents as continuing at delivery and does not date to 1941. Therefore using 1941 as this event's happening date is unsupported.
Persons
Neville Goddard
Wilhelmina Goddard
Joseph "Joe" Goddard (Neville's father)
Told / reported
  1. 6 April 1965 stated
    Source Spiritual StatesSpiritual States (nid 1770), telling 1770-5, told 1965-04-06
  2. 6 April 1965 estimated
    Source Spiritual Statescurrent certain delivery claim on nid 1770
    Reasoning Passage 543859 belongs to nid 1770, whose catalog and transcript chrome currently agree exactly on 1965-04-06; the inherited telling date is estimated.
Sources

Source

  • Spiritual States ¶69 (Let anyone criticize my mother—-she’s been gone since 1941—-I wouldn’t stand for it. She is my mother in this sphere and so she always will be in this sphere my mother.)