Neville begins lecturing to six sympathetic friends

At his very first meeting he sent out fifty penny postal cards to his theatrical friends and only six came, out of sympathy; too shy to charge, he passed a basket and each gave a dollar, which paid the rent, and he never turned back.
Date (happened)
c. 1938
unresolved
  1. c. 1938 stated · probable · preferred
    Source Binding and Loosing ¶36"In those days", told in Binding and Loosing (nid 1824)
  2. before 1964 bound · possible
    Source qualifying source passages 553267; telling lecture nids 2115
    Reasoning Qualifying passage ids [553267] belong to telling lecture nids [2115]. Each listed lecture contributes the selected safe envelope year 1964 (MAX of its non-refuted delivery years); 1964 is the MIN across telling lectures.
  3. before 14 January 1964 bound
    Source Passage recounts the first meeting retrospectively; carrier nid 2115 has a certain delivery date of 1964-01-14.
    Why More precise certain telling-ceiling bound appended beside the older possible year-only bound.
    Reasoning Neville says 'the first time I started' and describes the meeting as completed history, necessarily placing it before the carrier lecture. The carrier's certain 1964-01-14 delivery supplies the safe upper ceiling, while the passage supplies no exact occurrence date.
Persons
Told / reported
  1. 14 January 1964 estimated
    Source Carrier lecture nid 2115 has a supported certain delivery date of 1964-01-14.
    Why Missing carrier-derived told claim.
    Reasoning The event is told in nid 2115 and inherits its certain exact delivery date. Under the L4 node-source rule the derived event told claim is typed estimated, not stated.
Sources

Source

  • Binding and Loosing ¶36 (The first time I started, six people came, all through sympathy. I sent out fifty penny postal cards. In those days there was such a thing as a penny card, and I sent out the large amount of fifty cents worth.)
  • Binding and Loosing ¶36 (The first time I started, six people came, all through sympathy. I sent out fifty penny postal cards.)