Be What You Wish, Be What You Believe
Lecture catalog #6 — text: HAVE
Date (happened)
July 1951
stated · preferred
Source
CWB lectures index: July 1951, Station KECA radio talk
1951
stated
Source
Neville lectures catalog #6
c. July 1951
stated · possible
Source
passage 553078 (lecture nid 2101), live-text dateline 'Radio Talk, Station KECA, Los Angeles, July 1951'
Why
The lecture's fourth delivery claim (d2, 1958-01-14) is correctly excluded here - per the existing pair note (npr:25863), it belongs to the separate delivery recorded as hist_event 75.
Reasoning
This is an independent live-text dateline (distinct source from the existing catalog/CWB-index claims already on this event) corroborating the July 1951 date at month-level precision; no day is given.
14 January 1958
stated · doubtful
Source
Neville lectures catalog #77
Reasoning
Lowered to `doubtful` under the #2461 §1(b) extension of the #2435 standing rule. The fenced lecture that carried this date, nid 2101 "Be What You Wish, Be What You Believe", has had its claim at 1958-01-14 REFUTED, and no fenced lecture holds the date, so the assertion retains no support. This event cites that same node in field_sources (2101), so its support is circular: its only witness is a claim the corpus has withdrawn. ⛔ NOT `refuted`, deliberately: what was disproved is that THIS LECTURE was delivered on this day, NOT that Neville lectured that day at all — he spoke far more often than the surviving transcripts record. Refuting would assert the day did not happen, which nobody showed. Lowering withdraws the false confidence and keeps the day visible as calendar supply.
July 1951
stated · probable
Source
derived from the event's own title: "Neville radio talk in July 1951"
Reasoning
The event held NO date claim of any kind; its own title states 1951-07 (month precision, parsed as "month year"). ⚠ A title in this corpus is a DERIVED artefact — an earlier pass wrote it from the passage text — so this claim is title-derived and is marked as such rather than cited as a source document; the underlying text remains the real evidence and would supersede it. Confidence `probable`, never `certain`, for that reason. Precision is never inflated beyond the title's own wording. CALIBRATION (run v1.1/l1.4/titledate, against the 489 events that already hold an independent preferred date): day 96.1%, month 94.1% agreement. Titles naming a REFERENCE event rather than the event itself ("before", "after", "during the week of", "per ... lecture") are refused outright and never reach this write — reading an anchor as the date is the same laundering phase3b committed when it wrote telling dates onto events.
July 1951
stated
Source
passage 553078 header: Station KECA, Los Angeles, July 1951
Reasoning
The header directly identifies this radio talk as July 1951.
Sources
Source
Temporal reference