Abdullah tells Neville something in 1933

Neville recounted, in the lecture "The One Greater Than John," a specific statement Abdullah made to him in 1933.

Person: Neville Goddard

Date (happened)
1933
unresolved
  1. 1933 stated · preferred
    Source The One Greater Than John ¶5"in 1933 (I met him in ‘29)", told in The One Greater Than John (nid 1033)
  2. 1933 stated · probable
    Source Neville Goddard Abdullah Part 2 ¶5""He said to me in 1933 (I met him in '29)""
  3. 1933 stated · probable
    Source About Abdullah Neville Goddard Research New York"He said to me in 1933 (I met him in '29)...he did everything, he ate everything, he drank everything"
  4. 1933 stated
    Source Who Are the Condemned ¶51"back in 1933", told in Who Are the Condemned (nid 1148)
Place
72nd Street, New York City
Persons
Neville Goddard
Abdullah
Told / reported
  1. 10 March 1964 stated
    Source Who Are the CondemnedWho Are the Condemned (nid 1148), telling 1148-9, told 1964-03-10
  2. 9 January 1964 estimated · probable
    Source The One Greater Than Johnlecture nid 1033 ('The One Greater Than John'), delivery claim d1: 1964-01-09, stated/certain, catalog #174 -- the standing date per L7 adjudication #2363 (npr 88678)
    Reasoning The event's existing told claim (1969-01-30) derives from a delivery claim on nid 1033 that has since been refuted by L7 adjudication (#2363, shape catalogue_block_error; full evidence in npr 88678), which states the standing delivery date for this lecture is 1964-01-09. Per the rule against deriving from a refuted claim, the old told claim is left in place but is no longer trustworthy; this claim supplies the correct telling date. Confidence held at probable rather than certain because the surviving delivery claim is itself an unreviewed legacy catalog claim.
  3. 30 January 1969 stated · refuted
    Source The One Greater Than JohnThe One Greater Than John (nid 1033), telling 1033-5, told 1969-01-30
Sources

Source

  • Neville Goddard Abdullah Part 2 ¶5 ("He said to me in 1933 (I met him in '29)")
  • About Abdullah Neville Goddard Research New York ¶2 (He said to me in 1933 (I met him in '29)...he did everything, he ate everything, he drank everything)
  • The One Greater Than John ¶5 (And he said to me, “Now clothe yourself with Barbados. Put it on as you would another garment, just as you would another garment, so that you would smell the tropics and you would see what you would see were you in Barbados.”)
  • Who Are the Condemned ¶51 (Because when he told me this I was a strict vegetarian, teetotaler, celibate; I was everything that did nothing…that was Neville. Whatever man would do normally I didn’t do it; therefore, he said to me, “You know, you’re so good you’re good for nothing.”…)