Death of Jack Butler

Neville's secretary, Jack Butler, died suddenly and unexpectedly at age fifty, in or around August 1948, while Neville was on a lecture tour in California; he returned to New York for the funeral, which he gave as a Catholic service in Haverstraw, New York, where Jack was buried rather than cremated. Neville recounts that some six or seven months later he experienced a vision in which Jack appeared fully restored to youth, in his twenties, and did not know he had died.
Date (happened)
August 1948
unresolved
  1. August 1948 stated · preferred
    Source Truth Word God ¶13passage 552959: Jack died in 1948; quoted dialogue specifies August of last year
    Reasoning Neville explicitly opens the episode 'In 1948' and, within the same passage, identifies Jack's death as August of the preceding year relative to the vision six or seven months later, fixing August 1948 at month precision.
  2. c. August 1948 estimated · probable
    Source Baptism Into One Body ("Truth, the Word of God") ¶10passage 536679 (lecture nid 1310): 'Jack Butler, died quite suddenly in the year 1948, 48 or 49, I think it was 48, yes, 48, for he was born in 98 and he was just fifty when he died'; month corroborated by passage 536681, the vision dialogue: 'You died in the month of August of last year'.
    Why Day of month not given; passage 536681 also fixes the burial as Catholic, in Haverstraw, New York, not cremation.
    Reasoning He settles on 1948 after hedging, and the arithmetic he gives himself (born 1898, died at fifty) confirms 1948; the companion passage in the same lecture supplies the month, August, spoken by Neville in the reported vision conversation. Neither detail is a year mentioned in passing about something else -- both describe this death directly, so this is the happening date, not an aside.
Told / reported
  1. 24 November 1967 estimated
    Source Truth Word Godcertain preferred delivery claim on nid 2089
    Reasoning Passage 552959 belongs to nid 2089, independently dated 1967-11-24 certain by byline and catalog.
  2. 24 November 1967 estimated
    Source Baptism Into One Body ("Truth, the Word of God")delivery claim [d1] on lecture nid 1310, source node:1310, run v1.1/l2/w1 -- chrome dateline '11/24/67', independently corroborating the pre-existing legacy claim #393 (also 1967-11-24).
    Reasoning The lecture whose passage 536679 carries this telling is dated 1967-11-24 by two agreeing delivery claims; citing the transcript/chrome-sourced claim (d1) rather than the legacy catalog claim (d0) per lane guidance, though here both agree so there is no conflict to arbitrate.