The Power and the Wisdom

Lecture catalog #91 — text: HAVE

Date (happened)
3 November 1958
certain
  1. 3 November 1958 conclusion
    Why dc1-agreement-20261004, pm-actor-551 (PM 8702)
    Reasoning 1 claim, no conflict: 1958-11-03 (Neville lectures catalog #91).
  2. 3 November 1958 stated · preferred
    Source Neville lectures catalog #91
    Why pm-actor-551: Restored to its imported state: it was lowered and refuted only because transcript 1050 was paired here, and 1050 is event 465's delivery (PM 8749, 8758).
    Reasoning Lowered to `doubtful` under the #2461 §1(b) extension of the #2435 standing rule. The fenced lecture that carried this date, nid 1050 "The Power and the Wisdom", has had its claim at 1958-11-03 REFUTED, and no fenced lecture holds the date, so the assertion retains no support. This event cites that same node in field_sources (1050), so its support is circular: its only witness is a claim the corpus has withdrawn. ⛔ NOT `refuted`, deliberately: what was disproved is that THIS LECTURE was delivered on this day, NOT that Neville lectured that day at all — he spoke far more often than the surviving transcripts record. Refuting would assert the day did not happen, which nobody showed. Lowering withdraws the false confidence and keeps the day visible as calendar supply.
  3. 23 July 1968 stated · refuted
    Why pm-actor-551: Taken from transcript 1050 by exact title match; 1050 is event 465's delivery (dateline 07-23-1968), not catalogue #91's (PM 8749).
    Reasoning Exact title match to node 1050, whose delivery is certainly dated 1968-07-23.
Place
No place
Persons
Sources

Source