Neville begins studying with Abdullah

Date (happened)
1933
unresolved
  1. 1933 stated · probable · preferred
    Source Thinking Fourth-Dimensionally ¶34passage 527378 (lecture nid 989), 'It was back in 1933 in the city of New York, and my old friend Abdullah...'
    Reasoning Neville states the year directly and unhedged; confidence is capped at probable because it is a first-person recollection given fifteen years later, with no independent corroboration of the year itself.
Place
New York City
Persons
Neville Goddard
Told / reported
  1. 1948 estimated
    Source Thinking Fourth-Dimensionallydelivery claim d2 on lecture nid 989
    Reasoning The lecture recounting the Abdullah story is independently corroborated to 1948 by the transcript's own chrome header ('1948 Lesson 3'); the more precise 1948-02-23 catalogue claim (d0) is not used here because it is catalogue backfill only, and the competing 1964-02-03 claim (d1) is refuted and cannot be derived from.
Sources

Source